1816: The Year Without a Summer

Aerial view of Mount Tambora’s caldera on Sumbawa, Indonesia, 2011. Photo: Jialiang Gao / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0).

The phrase sounds like folklore. It was not.

In 1816, parts of northeastern North America and western Europe lost a growing season. Frost returned in months that were supposed to be warm. Snow fell in June in New England. Grain failed. Prices jumped. People called it the year without a summer, or, in New England, eighteen hundred and froze to death.

The cause was not a local cold snap. It was a mountain on the other side of the world.

What exploded

Mount Tambora stands on Sumbawa, in what is now Indonesia. In April 1815 it produced the largest eruption in recorded history — a VEI-7 event, a class that almost never happens in a human lifetime.

The main blast came around the 10th of April. The mountain lost a huge part of its height. Ash fell across the region. The explosion was heard more than 2,000 kilometres away.

Deaths on and near Sumbawa came in two waves. The first was the eruption itself: pyroclastic flows, collapsing roofs, ash. Modern reviews put that direct toll around 10,000 to 12,000 people. The second wave was hunger and disease after fields and water were ruined. Adding those deaths, careful counts land in the tens of thousands on the nearby islands. Some older tallies go higher. Nobody has a solid worldwide death count for the eruption and the bad harvests that followed.

That local disaster is not what made 1816 famous in Boston or Geneva. The famous part was what went into the sky and stayed there.

How a volcano steals a summer

Lava did not reach New England. Sulfur did.

A very large eruption injects sulfur dioxide into the stratosphere. There it turns into a haze of sulfate droplets. Those droplets reflect sunlight. Rain does not wash them out quickly, because they sit above the weather. The veil can last a year or more and spread around the globe.

The result is not a uniform ice age. It is a dimming. Average temperatures over the Northern Hemisphere dropped on the order of half a degree Celsius compared with the years just before — enough, in a world of subsistence farms and short growing seasons, to matter. Some reconstructions show a larger dip. Models of a Tambora-sized burst produce about a 1°C drop at the surface in 1816 and a weaker water cycle.

People at the time did not have that mechanism. In the northeastern United States they described a “dry fog” that wind and rain would not clear. The sun looked dim. Sunspots could be seen with the naked eye. Twilight ran to odd reds and purples. Those are the surface signs of a stratospheric veil, written down before anyone could name it.

Tambora was also not acting on a blank climate. A poorly identified tropical eruption around 1808–1809 had already loaded the stratosphere. The 1810s sat in a cooler stretch of the Dalton Minimum. Tambora was the blow that made 1816 infamous. It was not the only thing happening in the sky.

What “no summer” actually looked like

It did not mean the whole Earth skipped July.

It meant a ruined warm season in particular places.

In New England and nearby Canada, frost hit in months that farmers counted on. On 6 June 1816, snow was recorded in Albany, New York, and in Dennysville, Maine. Cape May, New Jersey, saw frost several nights running in late June. Corn was planted, killed, and planted again until it was too late. Hay failed. In parts of the interior, later writers said there were only two stretches of real summer weather.

The small stories that get retold are still useful if they stay small. Chauncey Jerome, a clockmaker in Connecticut, later wrote that on an early June morning he was walking to work in heavy wool and had to stop and put on mittens.

Oats are often said to have jumped from about 12 cents a bushel to about 92 cents. That figure comes from later accounts of the shortage. It shows how tight feed and grain became. It is not a national price index.

Families killed livestock they could not feed. Some people in Vermont later said they lived on nettles, wild turnips, and whatever they could hunt.

More families moved west, toward Ohio and milder country. The cold was not the only reason. It was one of them.

Western and central Europe had a different version of the same year: cold, wet, and late. Ireland took weeks of rain. Potatoes and grain suffered. Switzerland saw grain prices leap. Paris bread prices were reported to double in months. 1817 was remembered in parts of Germany as a year of beggars. Typhus spread in Ireland in the hungry years that followed. Linking every death in those epidemics to the volcano would overclaim. Linking crop failure, crowding, and disease is not a stretch.

China’s Yunnan province lost rice to cold and wet. The Indian monsoon was disrupted. Some historians connect that shock to later cholera spread from Bengal. That chain is debated. The weather disruption is not.

Eastern Europe and parts of Russia had a less brutal growing season and could still move grain. Port cities with access to trade suffered less than inland districts that ate only what they grew. Hunger followed the weather. It also followed who could still move grain, and who could not.

A wet summer on Lake Geneva

The same bad season kept a group of English writers indoors near Geneva.

In June 1816, rain kept a group of English writers indoors at Villa Diodati, near Geneva: Mary Wollstonecraft Godwin, who later published as Mary Shelley; Percy Shelley; Lord Byron; and John Polidori. Byron proposed they invent ghost stories. Shelley’s Frankenstein and Polidori’s vampire tale came out of that stay.

The eruption did not invent the novels. It only made the weather bad enough to cancel the lake. That footnote is true, and it is the part of 1816 everyone already knows.

What people thought was happening

In 1816 there was no global weather service and no satellite picture of an aerosol cloud.

Some blamed sunspots. Some blamed the end of the Napoleonic Wars, as if peace itself had cooled the air. A few naturalists already suspected volcanoes could dim the sun. Benjamin Franklin had wondered about that after Iceland’s Laki eruption in 1783. The full explanation came later: sulfur in the stratosphere, then a late, thin harvest. Ice cores, tree rings, and climate models now tie 1816 to Tambora’s sulfate spike.

That does not turn every local diary into a global average. It does show why so many places had the same kind of bad year at the same time.

What the year was not

It was not a planet without warmth. Tropics and many southern regions did not live the New England story.

It was not proof that one eruption sets the next century’s climate. The veil thinned. Harvests returned. The 1810s stayed awkward for a few more seasons, then the anomaly faded.

It was not a simple morality play. The people who died first were on Sumbawa, under ash, with ruined rice. The people who went hungry next were farmers at the edge of a short season, in an economy with thin reserves and slow wagons.

Closing

Nobody in Vermont needed a global mean temperature. They needed corn to ripen. A few tenths of a degree in a reconstruction can be frost in June in a field.

Smaller eruptions than Tambora — Pinatubo in 1991, for example — have cooled the planet measurably for a year or two. Nothing in the last two centuries has matched Tambora’s rank. The year without a summer was not a legend about sad weather. It was what a VEI-7 looks like when the ash has already fallen and the sunlight has not.

If you want the image, it is not a mountain on fire. It is a June morning in New England with mittens on, and a price list in which oats have become expensive.

1815 was the blast. 1816 was the weather it left behind.

SOURCES: Oppenheimer 2003 on Tambora; WIREs Climate Change review of the 1815 eruption (Raible et al., 2016); climate-model papers on Tambora forcing; U.S. National Park Service and New England diary records of 1816 frost and June snow; Royal Meteorological Society summaries of the European summer; standard volcanic-winter and ice-core sulfate literature.